Reflecting on the early signs of my husband’s ALS

How long before Todd's diagnosis did he start experiencing issues?

Written by Kristin Neva |

Main graphic for

Some people with ALS take a long time to get diagnosed, but in my husband’s case, I’ve often felt like the diagnosis came too quickly. Since there was no treatment that could have significantly altered the course of Todd’s disease, and since he ended up having a slow-progressing form of ALS, I sometimes think it would have been better not to have known what lay ahead, at least for a while longer.

Todd was diagnosed in June 2010, after only two months of seeking medical attention for a weak left arm. We did not spend years searching for a cause of the weakness, as is the case with some people with ALS.

The impetus for seeking medical care was when his left arm gave out as he carried a muffin and coffee to a morning meeting at work. He balanced the muffin on top of his notebook, using it like a tray, and held the cup of coffee with his right. As his left arm gave out, he braced the notebook against the wall with his body, unable to move without dropping the muffin or spilling the coffee. He stood in that position for about 10 seconds until a co-worker came up and offered a hand.

Recommended Reading
The screens of a computer and laptop show 0s and 1s.

AI voice analysis may help doctors spot early signs of ALS, study suggests

Todd thought perhaps it was a pinched nerve, and his primary doctor referred him to a spine care clinic for physical therapy. A doctor there suggested that his symptoms might be due to ALS, canceled his physical therapy, and referred him to a neurologist who diagnosed him with ALS. Todd went from thinking the worst-case scenario was that he would need neck surgery to learning he had ALS.

The neurologist asked when he had first experienced symptoms, and Todd recalled having trouble lifting our 3-year-old daughter out of her car seat the prior fall, about eight months earlier. But he didn’t think he had a problem 13 months earlier, because he had laid a paver patio in our backyard without issue. “The bricks were heavy, but they were bricks. I don’t think I had a problem then,” he told the doctor.

But the neurologist said that people swear up and down they were perfectly strong a week prior, but he can tell they’ve had months or years of motor-neuron damage. He said Todd had weakness in his right hand, too, which Todd hadn’t yet noticed.

Were there earlier signs?

After the diagnosis, Todd thought back over the last months and years, trying to figure out when he had first noticed symptoms. He remembered the car seat incident from the fall, and he specifically remembered struggling to lift weights the previous December. Over the Christmas holiday, he demonstrated to me and my parents by picking up a 3-pound jogging weight. Curling it, he said, it felt like 25 pounds.

For the longest time, he couldn’t remember any earlier signs of ALS before the fall of 2009.

But in 2017, a decade-old incident from three years before the diagnosis came to mind. He had attended a team-building activity, bowling with his department at work, and he scored about 125 on his first game, which was typical for him. In subsequent games, he would usually improve his score, but on that day, his score dropped to something like 100, and then to about 70. The ball felt heavy, and his wrist felt like it couldn’t support the ball on his backswing.

So maybe his ALS started in the fall of 2007.

We just got further confirmation that might be right, because last week, I got a note from an old friend of Todd’s sister. She reminisced that at his sister’s wedding weekend in July 2008, people were playing in his parents’ backyard, and a stray softball was heading for her young daughter’s head. Todd intercepted it at the last moment and told her that his arm had been acting up, and he was glad it was working right then.

Neither Todd nor I remembered that incident or that he had been having trouble with his arm at that time.

I’ve always felt like Todd got diagnosed super quickly, just eight months after the car seat incident and a couple months of searching for a cause. But in retrospect, perhaps we were blessed with a few years of blissful ignorance after all.


Note: ALS News Today is strictly a news and information website about the disease. It does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. This content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website. The opinions expressed in this column are not those of ALS News Today or its parent company, Bionews, and are intended to spark discussion about issues pertaining to ALS.

Leave a comment

Fill in the required fields to post. Your email address will not be published.

Comments are moderated. Once approved, your comment and username will be publicly visible. Please avoid sharing personal health information or other sensitive details.